Mourning a journalist in Mexico who said 'no to silence'

The World
Updated on
Valdez protest

It happened in broad daylight. On Monday, journalist Javier Valdez Cárdenas was driving near his office in Culiacán, the capital of the northern Mexican state of Sinaloa — the land of the Sinaloa Cartel and its former kingpin Joaquín "El Chapo" Guzmán Loera.

Around noon, assailants forced Valdez from his red Toyota Corolla and shot him a dozen times, according to Zeta, the Tijuana-based newsweekly. Valdez was left face down in the street, his signature Panama hat near his head.

He had also just filed his final article, about a protest in Culiacán against the deadly attacks teachers face by traveling and working in some of Sinaloa’s most dangerous areas. At least six teachers have been killed in the state so far this year.

Valdez is the sixth journalist murdered in Mexico in 2017. Since 1992, 40 journalists have been killed in the country for their work, according to the Committee to Protect Journalists — 32 of them with impunity. The Mexican government's own National Human Rights Commission counts at least 125 journalists killed in the country since 2000 — a death toll that makes Mexico one of the world's most dangerous places for reporters. 

Valdez's death is yet another "blow for the journalist community here," said Paulina Villegas, a Mexico City-based reporter with The New York Times.

The killing also adds to demands that Mexico’s government do more to protect press freedom. In April, CPJ met with Mexico’s president, Enrique Peña Nieto, to pressure his administration to make press freedom and the protection of journalists a higher priority. In early May, the government named a new prosecutor to lead a federal office created in 2006 to investigate crimes against the media. To date, of the 800-plus cases of attacks on journalists in the past six years, "only two of them have resulted in convictions," said Villegas.

In a press conference two days after the killing, Mexico's president, Enrique Peña Nieto, condemned the murder and said that federal officials would assist the authorities in Sinaloa to investigate it. So far, Sinaloa's attorney general has said that, at least initially, Valdez's murder was linked to his journalism. 

But considering the lack of convictions to date when it comes to murdered journalists, or of violent homicides in general in Mexico, skepticism of the government's willingness and ability to solve such crimes runs deep. During the press conference, Peña Nieto called for a minute of silence to honor murdered journalists. Instead, reporters shouted "Justice!" and "No more speeches! No more cover-ups of investigations!"

The response also owes to widespread accusations that collusion between local authorities and criminal groups is common, and that such collusion can generate attacks on the media. In this video, investigative journalist Marcela Turati calls for criminal investigations to examine ties between murdered journalists and politicians and to "not just blame the cartels":

On Tuesday, reporters across Mexico expressed outrage at the murder of yet another colleague. Vigils were held in the state of Veracruz, where several journalists have been murdered in just the past year.

"The feeling is if someone like him can get killed, even after 20 years of reporting crime, then what's the hope for all of the other unknown and starting-up journalists around the country?" says Villegas. 

Valdez’s family, his wife and two grown children, also held a memorial service in Culiacán. 

Valdez family at memorial

The family of slain journalist Javier Valdez Cárdenas attends his memorial service in Culiacán, in Sinaloa state, Mexico. 


Jesus Bustamante/Reuters 

Several media outlets in Mexico ceased publication for a day, including Animal Político, a popular news site based in Mexico City.

Animal Politico

On May 16, several news sites in Mexico ceased publication for a day in protest of slain local journalists. Mexico City-based Animal Político put on its front page the faces and names of reporters murdered in 2017.    

In Miami, Univision staff worked under a large projection of a photo of Valdez. 

More than 180 foreign correspondents in Mexico signed an open letter condemning the murder of journalists in Mexico.


Among the mourning is journalist Turati, from Mexico. She called Valdez a friend, and remembered him for his sense of humor, “always happy, joking, even in the bad moments.” He was also "devoted to his family and talked a lot about his children," Turati said. 

"He was like our older brother," she said of Valdez, who turned 50 years old in April.

For years, many journalists heading to report in Sinaloa considered it a must to meet with Valdez — for a beer, for guidance on reporting on organized crime, for "strategies to stay alive," as Turati put it. He was prolific when reporting on violence in his home state. He wrote for the Mexican national daily La Jornada and contributed to the AFP news agency. Valdez also wrote books, including “Miss Narco,” “Los Morros del Narco” ("Narco Youth") and “Narcoperiodismo” ("Narco Journalism"), about how “narco culture shaped life around him,” said Turati. In January, an English-language collection of his stories was published, titled “The Taken: True Stories of the Sinaloa Drug War.”

But Valdez made one of his biggest marks in 2003. That's when he co-founded Ríodoce, a regional newsweekly, for which he also wrote a column called “Malayerba” (slang for “bad weed”). It was known for chronicling how poverty and organized crime play out in everyday life.

At times, Ríodoce angered the powerful and dangerous. It is one of the few remaining news outlets in Sinaloa not dependent on government advertising, and it is respected for its coverage of crime and corruption in Mexico’s north. In 2009, a grenade was set off at the newsweekly’s office and, in 2011, the publication was forced offline for several days after a denial of service (DOS) attack. 
This year, Valdez alerted Article 19, a press freedom group, that an armed group had purchased massive amounts of a late February edition of Ríodoce. It remains unclear which article, in particular, they were trying to bury.

But Valdez refused to be silenced when it came to reporting on violence and corruption, joining other Mexican reporters determined to investigate and publish on the subject despite the dangers. "He said he had to talk and write about it because if nobody does it will be worse," said Turati. "He felt it was his duty."  

For that, he was recognized within Mexico and internationally. In 2011, Valdez received an International Press Freedom Award from the CPJ. He traveled to New York City, donned a tuxedo, and attended the organization’s annual ceremony in a ballroom at the Waldorf Astoria Hotel. “I have been a journalist these past 21 years and never before have I suffered or enjoyed it this intensely, nor with so many dangers,” Valdez said in his CPJ acceptance speech. “The youth will remember this as a time of war. Their DNA is tattooed with bullets and guns and blood, and this is a form of killing tomorrow. We are murderers of our own future.”

He continued: “This is a war, yes, but one for control by the narcos, but we the citizens are providing the deaths, and the governments of Mexico and the United States, the guns. And they, the eminent, invisible and hidden ones, within and outside of the governments, they take the profits.”

Yet despite his international profile, Valdez knew he was not protected. On March 23, after journalist Miroslava Breach was shot in front of her son in the northern border state of Chihuahua, Valdez tweeted: “Let them kill us all, if that is the death penalty for reporting this hell. No to silence.”


This story has been updated from its original version.

Sign up for our daily newsletter

Sign up for The Top of the World, delivered to your inbox every weekday morning.