At the US-Mexico border, caravan migrants weigh staying in Mexico or risking US expulsion

Reuters
Dozens of pigeons surround a man holding a small girl in his arms.

Hondurans, Guatemalans and Salvadorans who drew the wrath of President Donald Trump in a month-long caravan to the US border will make hard decisions on Sunday whether to risk being deported all the way home by trying to cross, or to build a life in Mexico. 

After angry tweets from Trump, US border authorities said some people associated with the caravan had been caught trying to slip through the fence, and encouraged the rest to hand themselves in to authorities. 

"We are a very welcoming country but just like your own house, we expect everyone to enter through our front door, and answer questions honestly," San Diego Chief Patrol Agent Rodney S. Scott said in a statement.   

Most of the group of about 400 travelers who arrived in border city Tijuana on buses over the past couple of days said they intended to legally seek asylum in San Diego later on Sunday, but lawyers advising the group gave them stark advice — not everyone will be successful.

RELATED: Make your way through the complex maze of asylum in the US

After the grueling journey, a somber mood took hold as the reality sank in that many of them would be separated from their families. Lovers and parents with slightly older sons and daughters could be forced to split up.

A woman hangs her hand and holds her hands together in prayer. Behind her, another woman has a hand outstretched toward her head. Another woman is in front of her.
A member of a migrant caravan from Central America and evangelical faithful pray in preparation for an asylum request in the U.S., in Tijuana, Mexico on April 28, 2018. Edgard Garrido/Reuters

At venues around the city, US immigration lawyers working on a pro bono basis on Saturday listened to harrowing tales of life in the immigrants' home countries.

Death threats from local gangs, the murder of family members, retaliatory rape, and political persecution back home prompted them to flee, the migrants and lawyers say.

Many of the immigrants who spoke at length with Reuters at various points during their trip through Mexico had been short on knowledge of their legal rights, but at least 24 recounted detailed stories of facing death threats.

As poor migrants from Central America on a perilous route through Mexico, they feared they could be robbed, raped, arrested and assaulted, so traveling by caravan offered their only protection, they said.

The lawyers advised which cases had higher chances of passing the "credible fear" test required to enter the long and often difficult US asylum process, said immigrant rights organization Al Otro Lado, Spanish for On the Other Side. 

"A lot will depend on how well they can articulate their case," said one of the pro bono lawyers, who preferred to remain anonymous.

RELATED: She escaped violence in El Salvador, but there's little time or resources to heal while seeking asylum in the US

The rest were advised to stay put in Mexico, which would remove the risk that US authorities fly them the more than 2,000 miles back home. 

"We'll wait and see," said Bryan Garcia, from Honduras, seated beside a 4-year-old Nicole, who was eating a strawberry biscuit as they waited for her mother to come out of a meeting with a lawyer.

Nicole and her mother are from El Salvador. They befriended Garcia along the caravan's journey and the adults had fallen for each other.

But Garcia would not be asking for asylum — he would stay in Tijuana, having already been deported once from the US. 

"We'll just have to try to stay connected," he said as Nicole paused from eating her biscuit and blinked up at him.

RELATED: With smuggling costs skyrocketing, parents balance risk and debt for their children's future

Trump has been pressuring Mexico to stop the migrants before they reached the border, linking the future of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) to Mexican efforts to stem the flow of Central Americans.

The friction has coincided with high-intensity efforts by US, Canadian and Mexican teams to renegotiate NAFTA on Trump's bidding, with officials saying a deal could be just a few weeks away after months of talks. 

Mexico deports tens of thousands of Central Americans every year back across its southern border with Guatemala.

Will you support The World? 

The story you just read is accessible and free to all because thousands of listeners and readers contribute to our nonprofit newsroom. We go deep to bring you the human-centered international reporting that you know you can trust. To do this work and to do it well, we rely on the support of our listeners. If you appreciated our coverage this year, if there was a story that made you pause or a song that moved you, would you consider making a gift to sustain our work through 2024 and beyond?