Is France in a cultural retreat?
PARIS — Before a looming cathedral, in the 11th arrondissement of Paris, a handful of children sat in a semicircle, knees hugging large wooden drums. Tac-tac-toom, they beat out, faces rigid with concentration. Tac-tac-toom. Parents looked on with admiring eyes. Tac-tac-toom. Other spectators paused, and then strolled on, beckoned by a melody echoing from farther down the street. The Paris chapter of the annual French music celebration, Fete de la Musique, had begun.
Twenty-seven years ago, Jack Lang, then France’s minister of culture, transformed Paris into a stage for the country’s first Fete de la Musique. On this day of free music musicians of all levels and experience pour into the streets, plucking, strumming and wailing out their ambitions to a roving audience of the musically-versed or just plain curious. Since Lang’s time, Fete de la Musique has spread from Paris to cities around the world.
This year’s festival in France revolved around the theme of 50 years of French song, broadly interpreted. The mellow tones of Bossa Nova, the craze of Klezmer and an homage to greats like Piaf and Gainsbourg collided in the open air. Paris alone hosted nearly 390 performances.
So why is there a raging debate over whether France is still the cradle of culture it once was?
“France today is a wilting power in the global cultural marketplace,” wrote Donald Morrison of Time magazine in 2007.
“The modern world has sucked out some [of Paris’] essence, leaving a film-set perfection hollowed out,” wrote Roger Cohen last year in the New York Times.
Most recently, French President Nicolas Sarkozy reportedly attacked Paris’ mayor, Bertrand Delanoe, for lacking ambition regarding the capital’s cultural and urban development.
But Fete de la Musique sits at the helm of France’s festival-laden summer. The Festival d’Avignon, a theater festival in the South of France, is in full swing. The Cannes Film Festival just wrapped up. This week, Paris plays host to the 26th Chopin Festival, a jazz festival and the Fete du Cinema.
The throngs of people who gathered in the Place Sainte Marthe, in Paris’ 10th arrondissement, on Sunday, were not deterred by the pessimists of old media and politics. A temporary stage had been erected in the square, and at almost midnight a group performing covers of Malian singer Ali Farka Toure took to the stage. Audience members danced, bounced and stood cramped into the space that the small square afforded.
Pedro Viana, 22, a medical student at French university Paris Sud, stood to the side of the crowd. “I came because of the free music,” he explained. “Street life is much more important tonight than other nights. I didn’t go into any bars or anything.”
Each year, France’s government pours millions of euros into the Ministry of Culture in order to sustain and support the creation of art and events like Fete de la Musique.
“People say culture here is getting worse,” Viana continued. “That it’s not what it used to be. I think it’s a world of opportunity. Here, if you’re interested in a particular thing, you can find five or six guys who are into the same thing.”
Marc Levend, 31, a music teacher, had spent the earlier parts of Sunday playing an accompaniment for students on the outskirts of Paris. Levend said that France’s cultural scene was diverse.
“There are certain spots and scenes that are good,” Levend explained. “There are lots of milieus. You have to dive into a particular one to see what’s happening.”
While these onlookers described a dynamic culture scene in France, perhaps what critics have correctly observed is that it is no longer the French themselves setting the agenda.
“Today France is influenced,” Levend explained. “There’s the idea that France is multicultural, and there is music arriving from these other countries.”
Six hours behind and more than 3,000 miles away, New York City was mid-way through its third annual Make Music New York festival. More than 875 concerts were held in the open air that Sunday in New York, and like the 100 other countries that host similar events, New York’s free music day was based on the original in France.
More on music:
The story you just read is accessible and free to all because thousands of listeners and readers contribute to our nonprofit newsroom. We go deep to bring you the human-centered international reporting that you know you can trust. To do this work and to do it well, we rely on the support of our listeners. If you appreciated our coverage this year, if there was a story that made you pause or a song that moved you, would you consider making a gift to sustain our work through 2024 and beyond?