South Africa’s most famous cartoonist considers what to do with statues of white oppressors

The World
On April 9th in Pretoria, South African Afrikaner singer Sunette Bridges chained herself to the statue of former Boer leader Paul Kruger, known as the father of the Afrikaner nation, to protest against calls for its removal. The statue was covered in gree

South Africa's best known cartoonist, Jonathan Shapiro, is not afraid to look controversy in the eye, draw a cartoon, and endure the outrage of those offended by it.  

Known by his pen name Zapiro, he's twice been sued for defamation by South African President Jacob Zuma and he was roundly scolded in 2010 when he drew a Mohammed cartoon for Everybody Draw Mohammed Day.  

His courage, or some would say brazenness, has also made him an early observer of some of South Africa’s most vexing social-political issues, including one that has been in the news recently: What to do with the statues of figures from the country’s apartheid past?

Last week, the statue of white mining magnate Cecil Rhodes was taken down from the campus of the University of Cape Town after weeks of protest.  While the university was built on land donated by Rhodes, he was deeply racist and helped lay the groundwork for apartheid, helping to push through legislation which established “native reserves,” or specific areas in the country where blacks could own property.

“He basically invented apartheid based on that idea of so-called native reserves," Zapiro says.

The removal of Rhodes' statue has sparked a larger debate within South Africa about what to do with statues of similar figures throughout the country. It’s an issue Zapiro is deeply familiar with. He's been cartooning about it since 1994. 

Zapiro entiled this
Zapiro entiled this "Creatures from the Apartheid Era."Zapiro, Mail & Guardian, September 15, 1994Reprinted with permission from zapiro.com. All rights reserved. 

Zapiro, who is white, used to walk by the Rhodes statue almost daily when he was a student at the University of Cape Town in the late 1970s. "We were aware of Rhodes. We were aware of those kinds of symbols, but I don't think, except for a few good lefties, not enough was made of the symbolic importance of what was there."

Zapiro compares the BBC's decision to fire Jeremy Clarkson, popular host of Top Gear, with the pressure from students at University of Cape Town to remove the statue of Cecil Rhodes from campus. Zapiro concludes both Rhodes and Clarkson are relics of the
Zapiro compares the BBC's decision to fire Jeremy Clarkson, popular host of Top Gear, with the pressure from students at University of Cape Town to remove the statue of Cecil Rhodes from campus. Zapiro concludes both Rhodes and Clarkson are relics of the past.  Zapiro, The Times, South Africa, March 26, 2015Reprinted with permission from zapiro.com. All rights reserved. 

Nearly 40 years after his own time at the University of Cape Town, Zapiro is pleased that the statue has been removed, but with a caveat: "I thought perhaps the statue could move to one end of campus where it wasn't particularly obvious and then put something important in its place.

Zapiro notes the domino effect that could see the removal of a number of statues in South Africa, starting with British colonizier Cecil Rhodes, Queen Victoria, Paul Kruger and Jan van Riebeck, a Dutch colonial administrator and founder of Cape Town.
Zapiro notes the domino effect that could see the removal of a number of statues in South Africa, starting with British colonizier Cecil Rhodes, Queen Victoria, Paul Kruger and Jan van Riebeck, a Dutch colonial administrator and founder of Cape Town.Zapiro, Mail & Guardian, April 10, 2015Reprinted with permission from zapiro.com. All rights reserved.
I don't believe in the destruction of any of these things."

Zapiro believes the visual artifacts from the apartheid era need to be preserved, perhaps in a museum or "tucked away in some corner" to educate future generations of South Africans about their past.

Busts of South African leaders 1948 to 1989, Apartheid's fiercest proponents and enforcers including D.F. Malan, J.G. Strijdom, Hendrik Verwoerd, B.J. Vorster, and P.W. Botha.
Busts of South African leaders 1948 to 1989 include Apartheid's fiercest proponents and enforcers including D.F. Malan, J.G. Strijdom, Hendrik Verwoerd, B.J. Vorster, and P.W. Botha.  Zapiro, Sowetan, South Africa, February 6, 1996Courtesy zapiro.com, All Rights Reserved. 

Zapiro spent the first 10 years of his career as an anti-apartheid satirical rabble-rouser. Then, after Nelson Mandela was elected in 1994,  a push begn to remove the statues of apartheid's worst oppressors, like Hendrik Verwoerd, the South African politician who brought the National Party to power in 1948.

In 1997, President Nelson Mandela commemorated the South African public holiday Heritage Day with a speech at Robben Island, his former place of captivity which had just opened as a museum. In the speech, Mandela discussed the need to reject transform Apa
President Nelson Mandela commemorated the South African public holiday Heritage Day in 1997 with a speech at Robben Island, his former place of captivity. In the speech, Mandela discussed the need to reject transform Apartheid's narrow view of South African heritage to one that embraced all South Africans. Zapiro, Sowetan, South Africa, September 27, 1997Reprinted with permission from zapiro.com. All rights reserved.
"Verwoerd really refined apartheid into the disgusting, inhumane system that it was," he says.  

Then, in 2001, a strange force-of-nature event sealed the fate of a statue of another apartheid heavyweight: J.G. Strijdom, an uncompromising Afrikaner nationalist who served as prime minister during the 1950s.

"There was a giant, fascist, granite statue of Strijdom in Strijdom Square in Pretoria," says Zapiro. "I certainly don't believe in anything super natural or anything like that, but it was absolutely incredible. Suddenly there was this massive collapse of this old square." Inexplicably, the giant bust of Strijdom split in two on May 31, 2001. It was the 40-year anniversay of the day that South Africa was declared a republic. 

On May 31 2001, the 40th anniversary of South Africa becoming a republic, a massive sculptured head of 1950s Apartheid leader J.G. Strijdom crashed and tumbled into a parking garage below in Pretoria. The large granite monument plaza dedicated to Strijdom
On May 31 2001, the 40th anniversary of South Africa becoming a republic, a massive sculptured head of 1950s Apartheid leader J.G. Strijdom crashed and tumbled into a parking garage below in Pretoria. The large granite monument plaza dedicated to Strijdom was virtually demolished in the incident.   Zapiro, Sunday Times, South Africa, June 3, 2001Reprinted with permission from zapiro.com. All rights reserved.

There are many statues of Mandela around South Africa (though Zapiro dislikes the quality of most of them), but none in a really prominent place. Zapiro notes that there has yet to be a direct replacement of a statue of an apartheid-era politician with one of Mandela. A statue of Louis Botha, the first prime minister of the Union of South Africa, the forerunner of the modern South African state still stands in front of South Africa's parliament in Pretoria.

"He was very much an oppressor of black people." The statue shows Botha sitting proudly on horseback. "That is the most obvious symbol as you approach parliament. And that has been seen as a huge eyesore for a lot of people."

Nelson Mandela is elected President of South Africa in 1994 and starts his first day in office observed by those who proceeded him. Reactions are from former National Party prime ministers and presidents who ruled during Apartheid.
Nelson Mandela is elected President of South Africa in 1994 and starts his first day in office observed by the Apartheid rulers who proceeded him. Zapiro, Mail & Guardian, South  Africa, May 12, 1994Reprinted with permission from zapiro.com. All rights reserved.

Recently, a large bust of Nelson Mandela and a standing statue of Walter and Albertina Sisulu, huge icons of the struggle to end apartheid, have been added to the parliament grounds, but they're not prominent. "The big symbol that stands outside is still Louis Botha. And in so many respects you have this sort of thing where either the big areas haven't changed or haven't changed enough."

Zapiro titled this cartoon:
Zapiro titled this cartoon: "Evolution of Democracy in South Africa". From Hendrik Verwoerd, the architecht of Apartheid to present day Jacob Zuma. The cartoon is based on the well-known timeline picture "evolution of man."Zapiro, Mail & Guardian, August 19, 2010Reprinted with permission from zapiro.com, All rights reserved.
Do you support journalism that strengthens our democracy?

At The World, we believe strongly that human-centered journalism is at the heart of an informed public and a strong democracy. We see democracy and journalism as two sides of the same coin. If you care about one, it is imperative to care about the other.

Every day, our nonprofit newsroom seeks to inform and empower listeners and hold the powerful accountable. Neither would be possible without the support of listeners like you. If you believe in our work, will you give today? We need your help now more than ever!